New York Times: Doctors at Cornell University Report Distilled Water is Safe to Drink and Does Not Leach Minerals
DISTILLED WATERS KNOWLEDGE: THE STATEMENTS OF TWO CORNELL UNIVERSITY DOCTORS, WHO ARE EXPERTS IN THE FIELD OF WATER QUALITY AND NUTRITION, CONFIRM DISTILLED WATER IS SAFE TO DRINK AND DOES NOT LEACH MINERALS
The New York Times – A version of this article appeared in print on September 9, 2008, on page F2 of the New York edition…
Q & A
By C. CLAIBORNE RAY
Published: September 8, 2008
Q. Is it safe to drink distilled water? Does it leach minerals out of the body?
A. It is safe, and it does not leach out minerals, two experts on water quality and nutrition at Cornell agree. But they questioned drinking distilled water when water can be made safe with far less energy than distillation takes.
Joseph H. Hotchkiss, professor of food science, said that accepting the idea that distilled water could draw minerals out of the body would mean assuming that it was not actually absorbed into the body.
“The inside of your body is a lot like a tube,” Dr. Hotchkiss explained, with membranes inside to isolate what you eat from the body. The membrane controls what crosses it, and if water did not cross that membrane, it would pass directly through the body, causing diarrhea. Instead, distilled water is absorbed like other water, and its excretion is controlled by the kidneys.
Distilled water lacks minerals and has a flat taste, Dr. Hotchkiss said, but he pointed out that except for iron and calcium in women of childbearing age, minerals are not in short supply in the United States diet, and water is not a significant source of minerals anyway.
The water-quality expert, Ann T. Lemley, a professor in the College of Human Ecology, agreed that distilled water was safe. Most dissolved substances get removed when water is distilled, Dr. Lemley said, including salts and most potential contaminants.
“The high temperature of distillation kills microbiological content,” Dr. Lemley said, “one for-sure advantage of distilled water.” It might be valuable for an immune-compromised person, she said, but advanced filtration would also work. C. CLAIBORNE RAY
Readers are invited to submit questions by mail to Question, Science Times, The New York Times, 620 Eighth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10018-1405, or by e-mail to email@example.com.
To see the original article, go here…